Friday, February 24, 2017

Putting the fun on the page

How good should a model be to appear in a magazine?

I ask, because for the last few months, I've been watching and taking part in a couple of model railway groups on Facebook. these are filled with people enjoying their hobby - but not in a way you see in print.

Posts often include photos of the latest Hornby train set purchased or roundy-roundy layouts on large boards in spare rooms and attics. There are also videos taken of people running trains.

There are two common features:

1 - The models would look terrible when subjected to the scrutiny of a camera
2 - The owners are having terrific fun with them

I remember a friend describing people leaving shows with a bag of track - "They are going home to do the train set tonight".

It's true. That bag of track represented a great deal of fun. Not the fun of the sort of modeller who obsesses over every detail or worries about the correct setting they are creating. The sort of fun that says you can have a Blue Pullman and US "Big Boy" on the same layout because you really like both of them.

The people you see in print and at shows are, I suspect, the top 20% of modellers. That's top in the sense of producing the "best" quality work, and it's little more than a finger in the air guesstimate of numbers.

In addition there will be a large number who never actually make anything but even then, I bet half the people in this hobby only ever get to see their models in print in the "Readers layouts" pages of a magazine. I wonder how many people skip over that as the pictures don't generally match up with those taken by the professional staff on all the other pages.

It's a bit like the "Gallery" section of Take Hart, a TV show I remember from my childhood. When I hear the tune Left Bank Two, I still shiver from the memory of the dull bit where were were exposed to the daubs of other children my age. At the time I just wanted to see Morph do something funny or Tony make some more art but in hindsight, I can only imagine the pride any youngster felt seeing their picture on telly.

Those readers models represent some of the great fun on offer in our hobby but it's nearly impossible to encapsulate this on the printed page. Even on video, watching someone else's railway full of straight from the box ready to run models thrashing round can't to convey they pleasure the owners get from them.

Every so often, someone will say that models in mags are too good and we should have some more attainable stuff on show.  How do you define attainable though? Straight from the box? For many that's as far as they go, but would they then want to see lines of factory fresh models in a magazine they have paid for?

Railway modelling is fun. And it's fun in many different ways - all of which are equally valid no matter what some keyboard warrior tries to say. To my mind, even if you just run a train around a circle on the dining room table, it's better than sitting slack-jawed in front of the TV every night.

Maybe it's not possible to show all this. Perhaps only experiencing the joy of model making can explain what we get out of it. I'd like to think that there are other angles which is why I've written this post. I'm thinking out loud at the moment. Please join in the conversation in the comments.

6 comments:

Anonymous said...

i fully agree the Press can be inspirational, overwhelming, and discouraging all at the same time.

"...The people you see in print and at shows are, I suspect, the top 20% of modellers. That's top in the sense of producing the "best" quality work ... "

every time i see what appears to be the "best" modeler, i turn the page a see one better. rather than be daunted, i reflect where i've been, where i am now, and possible where i can be.

Jeffrey Showell said...

I always got some inspiration for Railway Modeller's "Junior Modeller" feature that they used to run. The inspiration came from the youngsters' enthusiasm for their layouts, expressed in their own words, as much as from their results. And some of their models were very nice.

bartholomew sorrentino said...

I really do get tired of the constant drumbeat to be inspired to raise one's level of modeling toward someone who has just raised the bar to a higher level. I envy those who run trains with friends, have some fun, and then have coffee, cookies and gab about real and model railways.

Kelly Harding said...

Nothing at all wrong with what you posted about the Facebook groups. If those people are having fun and happy, great.

We have to remember they allow the manufacturers to produce the models. If only the print suitable modellers bought the models they'd never release anything, which is why I am often left having the classic head to wall moment with some keyboard warriors having a go at such people enjoying themselves with such things as 'tgst didn't run in that location in that livery' etc.

The modelling press should be both trying to help people improve and have fun and showcasing the best there is. Balancing it is difficult, and something I'm faced with now I'm a society magazine editor.

That society has seemingly gotten a reputation for the only content suitable being super accurate and p4 etc, which is not the case at all, all abilities should be encouraged in that respect.

Andrew Howard said...

I think that it is what makes our hobby so appealing. I appreciate the fact that Metcalfe terraces can be exhibited on a layout next to one with Pendonesque buildings. It is seeing what people have achieved with off the shelf products, how they have personalised them, that inspires me in my modelling.

Evan Batchelor said...

I can remember as a lad agonising over building the “perfect” hornby layout, and in most cases not even attempting to start when I realised things didnt quite stack up. Then one week we had cousins come to stay and they wanted to play with the trains. We setup a double oval with sidings on the Lounge table and had an absolute blast. Moral of the story: Enjoying a train means actually getting it out and playing with it, not leaving it in a box.